LBReport.com

News / AUDIO

CA Same Sex Marriage Pioneer Robin Tyler Pleased With Prop 8 Outcome For CA, But Urges Continued Focus On Ensuring Marriage Equality Nationwide

by Joe Mello
LBREPORT.com Community Correspondent



LBREPORT.com's extended special event coverage is made possible by:

We are dedicated to helping you find simple solutions to life’s more complex problems. Audrey Stephanie Loftin has been practicing in Long Beach, California since July of 1990. Reba Birmingham has been practicing Law since 1998. Our firm serves the Los Angeles & Orange County areas, with an emphasis on Civil, Criminal, Probate and Family Law. When you need a lawyer, or simply require further information about your current situation, please call (562) 621-6300 to schedule a consultation...and for further information about us, CLICK HERE.
(June 26, 2013, 1:10 p.m., updated 2:50 p.m.) -- CA same sex marriage pioneer Robin Tyler spoke with LBREPORT.com minutes after the U.S. Supreme Court issued 5-4 rulings that let CA's Prop 8 fall (which had barred same sex marriages in CA) and struck down the federal Defense of Marriage Act (that had barred federal benefits to legally married same sex couples).

Ms. Tyler, with partner Diane Olson, became the first lesbian couple married in Los Angeles County (May 2008) after their lawsuit prevailed in the CA Supreme Court...after which CA voters passed Proposition 8 which ended the short lived window for CA same-sex marriages.

Ms. Tyler (who led an inaugural "Dyke March" during Long Beach Pride Week in January) prefaced her comments with the caveat that at early morning she hadn't yet read the full Court opinions or spoken with a lawyer on the rulings...but said she was pleased that Prop 8 had fallen and along with portions of the federal Defense of Marriage Act.

However she also reiterated her frequently stated view that the movement's focus should remain on ensuring marriage equality not just in California but nationwide.

To hear salient portions of her remarks, click here.

UPDATE, 2:45 p.m.: Ms. Tyler issued the following written statement at midafternoon:

[begin Tyler written statement] Diane and I were thrilled that DOMA was struck down, and that we and other same-sex married couples, including those in the military, will receive Federal Benefits. We hope this will solve the problem for the tens of thousands of bi-national couples.

However, we were less excited about Proposition 8 not being ruled on because of "lack of legal standing." Yes, we are very excited that the freedom to marry will return to California. (Although we still worry and wonder why the case wasn't filed on behalf of the two terrific couples and as a class action suit as well?) This could possibly mean that someone might challenge the ruling as just applying to these 2 couples, or at least leave it open to interpretation.

The Supreme Court ruling on Prop 8 was extremely narrow which is why some of the liberal justices disagreed. In effect, rather then ruling, they just sent it back to California. Then why did the justices accept the case?

All of the major figures in the mid-20th century African American Civil rights movements firmly rejected that notion of 'states rights,' because they knew that enshrining 'states rights' over 'civil rights' would only delay full equality.

We know this also. So while we celebrate today, we know of the tremendous amount of work that has to be done. Yesterday's reversal of the successful 'voting rights act' shows how easily rights can be reversed.

So, now, more then ever, we need to keep fighting, not just for the freedom to marry nationally, but for ENDA, housing, and a comprehensive national civil rights bill that protects our entire community. Because Justice is not about Just Us.


Related LBREPORT.com Coverage:

  • Marriage Equality Supporters Invite Public To Free Event Tonight @ The Grand; LBREPORT.com Will Carry LIVE WEBCAST VIDEO AND
  • What's Next For Marriages in CA; UPDATE: Includes Letter From CA Att'y Gen'l Harris to Gov. Brown With Instructions To County Clerks re Same Sex Marriages; At News Conference, AG Harris Urges 9th Circuit To Lift Stay Immediately by Joe Mello, LBREPORT.com Community Correspondent
    AND
  • Reactions As Received To U.S. Supreme Court Rulings On Prop 8 and Defense of Marriage Act
    AND
  • CA Same Sex Marriage Pioneer Robin Tyler Pleased With Prop 8 Outcome For CA, But Urges Continued Focus On Ensuring Marriage Equality Nationwide AND
  • CA's Prop 8 (Banning Same Sex Marriage) And Fed'l Defense of Marriage Act (Barring Fed'l Benefits For Same Sex Couples) Are Dead; See Full U.S. Supreme Court Rulings Here

    Follow LBReport.com w/

    Twitter

    RSS

    Facebook

    Return To Front Page

    Contact us: mail@LBReport.com




  • Ad above provided in the public interest by:














    Carter Wood Floors
    Hardwood Floor Specialists
    Call (562) 422-2800 or (714) 836-7050





    blog comments powered by Disqus

    Return To Front Page

    Contact us: mail@LBReport.com


    Copyright © 2013 LBReport.com, LLC. All rights reserved. Terms of Use/Legal policy, click here. Privacy Policy, click here